(916) 775-8542 
Successor Trustee Disputes: When Siblings Battle for Control of the Family Trust
Trusts are designed to bring clarity, stability, and fairness to the management of family wealth. But in practice, they can often become battlegrounds—especially when siblings are involved. When the parents are gone and a successor trustee takes the reins, simmering rivalries, perceived favoritism, and disagreements over money can explode into full-scale legal warfare.
At Hackard Law, we frequently represent clients in these highly charged trust disputes. In particular, conflicts between siblings over control of a family trust can fracture relationships beyond repair and threaten the very assets the trust was meant to protect. This blog explores why sibling trustee disputes arise, how California law governs trustee succession and fiduciary duties, and what beneficiaries can do when trust turns to turmoil.
Understanding the Role of the Successor Trustee
A successor trustee is the person named in a trust document to manage and distribute trust assets after the original trustee—often a parent—dies or becomes incapacitated. This individual wields significant power, including:
- Managing trust property (real estate, investments, bank accounts)
- Paying debts and taxes
- Making distributions to beneficiaries
- Keeping accurate records and providing accountings
- Upholding fiduciary duties of loyalty, impartiality, and care
While these responsibilities are clear on paper, emotions and family dynamics can make them difficult to carry out in practice—especially when siblings are beneficiaries.
Why Sibling Trustee Disputes Are So Common
Sibling trustee disputes often reflect decades of unresolved family tension, not just disagreements over money. Deep-rooted family dynamics, perceived injustices, and the struggle for legacy and control all play a role. Some common catalysts include:
1. Perceived Favoritism
If one sibling is named trustee while others are beneficiaries, it may be interpreted as a sign of favoritism. This can stir resentment, particularly if the trustee is believed to be managing the trust for their own benefit.
2. Lack of Transparency
Beneficiaries have the right to know how the trust is being managed. If a sibling trustee fails to provide regular accountings, explain decisions, or share documents, suspicion builds quickly.
3. Self-Dealing or Mismanagement
When a sibling trustee pays themselves excessive fees, uses trust funds for personal expenses, or makes questionable investments, other siblings may accuse them of breaching fiduciary duties.
4. Unequal Distributions
Even if a trust provides for equal distributions, disputes often arise over timing, conditions, or interpretations of vague provisions.
5. Longstanding Rivalries
Old wounds resurface when one sibling gains power over others. Even trivial disagreements can escalate when fueled by decades of unresolved tension.
Legal Grounds for Challenging a Successor Trustee
California law offers beneficiaries several paths to challenge a sibling trustee whose actions raise red flags. Key legal arguments include:
1. Breach of Fiduciary Duty
Trustees owe the highest duty of care and loyalty. Breaches can include:
- Self-dealing or conflicts of interest
- Failure to act impartially among beneficiaries
- Poor investment decisions
- Failure to distribute assets timely
- Lack of transparency
Beneficiaries may petition the court to remove the trustee, surcharge them (i.e., make them personally liable for losses), or compel them to perform their duties.
2. Failure to Account
Under Probate Code § 16060, trustees must keep beneficiaries reasonably informed. If a sibling trustee withholds accountings or documents, a beneficiary can demand judicial intervention.
3. Lack of Capacity or Undue Influence
If the trust was amended late in a parent’s life under suspicious circumstances—such as naming one sibling as sole trustee or sole beneficiary—other siblings may challenge the amendment based on lack of capacity or undue influence.
4. Removal for Cause
Probate Code § 15642 allows courts to remove a trustee for:
- Misconduct
- Hostility impairing administration
- Failure to act
- Conflict of interest
- Any other reason it’s in the trust’s best interest
For a deeper dive into how family inheritance battles unfold—and how to fight back—consider reading Inheritance Heists by Michael Hackard. The book shares insights and real cases that reveal the strategies behind trust disputes and estate litigation.
Case Study: When Sibling Disputes Go to Court
The Scenario:
Two brothers and one sister are equal beneficiaries of their parents’ trust. The oldest brother is named successor trustee. After their father dies, he delays distributing assets, refuses to share financial records, and moves into the family home without paying rent. The other siblings grow frustrated and suspect self-dealing.
The Legal Strategy:
The beneficiaries hire Hackard Law to petition the probate court for:
- An order compelling the trustee to provide a full accounting
- Suspension and removal of the trustee for breach of fiduciary duty
- Surcharge for losses due to unpaid rent and missed investment opportunities
The Outcome:
The court finds the trustee failed to uphold his duties and orders his removal. A neutral third-party professional trustee is appointed, and the trust assets are eventually distributed fairly.
Can You Avoid or Resolve Trustee Disputes Without Litigation?
Yes—but it takes proactive communication, smart planning, and sometimes mediation. Families can reduce the risk of sibling conflict by:
1. Choosing the Right Trustee
Instead of naming one child, parents can appoint:
- A professional fiduciary
- A neutral third party
- Co-trustees (with caution, as this can also lead to stalemates)
2. Clear Trust Language
Well-drafted trusts that spell out duties, timelines, and distribution schedules leave less room for interpretation or manipulation.
3. Early Communication
If you’re the trustee, communicate frequently with siblings. Share accountings, explain decisions, and seek input to build trust.
4. Mediation and Alternative Dispute Resolution
In many cases, a trained mediator can help siblings reach agreement without going to court. This preserves relationships and avoids costly litigation.
How Hackard Law Helps in Sibling Trustee Battles?
Our team at Hackard Law is well-versed in the emotional and financial complexities of trust litigation. When a trustee’s actions harm beneficiaries—or when false accusations threaten a rightful trustee—we bring decades of experience to the table.
We assist clients with:
- Petitions to remove a trustee
- Defense of trustees accused of misconduct
- Compelling accountings
- Challenging or defending trust amendments
- Mediating family disputes
- Litigating for recovery of lost assets or damages
We understand that these cases aren’t just about money—they’re about legacy, fairness, and family, requiring not only legal skill but also compassion and perspective to guide our clients through the most difficult moments.
When to Call a Trust Litigation Attorney?
If you’re in one of the following situations, it may be time to seek legal help:
- A sibling trustee refuses to share information
- You suspect mismanagement or self-dealing
- The trustee won’t make distributions
- Someone accuses you of wrongdoing as a trustee, but you believe you’ve acted in good faith.
- The trust documents are confusing or potentially invalid
- Your sibling is using trust assets to their advantage
Involving legal counsel early helps you protect your rights and prevent lasting damage.
Final Words
Sibling trustee disputes are some of the most painful—and preventable—legal battles we see within family trusts. One child gaining power over others brings longstanding tensions and fairness issues to the surface.
What starts as a disagreement over paperwork can quickly evolve into accusations of betrayal and abuse.
At Hackard Law, we help families navigate this minefield. Whether you’re a beneficiary facing a stonewalling sibling trustee or a trustee who wants to do the right thing but feels overwhelmed, we offer clear legal guidance, strong representation, and an unwavering commitment to justice.
If you’re facing a sibling trust dispute, don’t wait until things get worse. Call Hackard Law – (916)-775-8542 for a confidential consultation. Let’s work together to protect your family’s legacy—and your peace of mind.