(916) 775-8542 
Using Accounting Disputes to Challenge a Trustee’s Management
In the world of trust administration, numbers tell a story—and sometimes, that story reveals betrayal, neglect, or mismanagement. Trust beneficiaries rely on trustees to act with integrity, transparency, and accountability. When a trustee fails to meet these expectations, the first sign of trouble often appears in the trust’s financial records.
At Hackard Law, we’ve handled countless cases where vague, inconsistent, or missing accountings opened the door to successful litigation. Whether the issue is negligence or outright abuse, beneficiaries have the right—and sometimes the responsibility—to challenge a trustee’s management when the numbers don’t add up.
This blog explores how trust accounting disputes can serve as the gateway to uncovering mismanagement, misappropriation, or breaches of fiduciary duty. We’ll examine the legal framework, common red flags, strategic considerations, and how to take effective legal action.
I. The Trustee’s Duty to Account: A Legal Obligation, Not a Favor
California law is clear: trustees have a fiduciary duty to provide regular and accurate accountings to beneficiaries. These accountings serve as both a transparency tool and a safeguard against abuse.
A. What the Law Requires
Under California Probate Code §16062, trustees must provide a formal accounting:
- At least annually
- At the termination of the trust
- Upon a change of trustee
- Upon reasonable request by a beneficiary
The accounting must include:
- A statement of receipts and disbursements
- A statement of assets and liabilities
- A statement of trustee compensation
- Disclosure of any third-party transactions involving the trustee
Failing to produce a timely and complete accounting is a breach of fiduciary duty—and often a red flag for deeper problems.
II. Why Trustees Resist or Delay Accountings
Not every delayed accounting is an act of bad faith—but in many cases, hesitation is a sign of fear. Trustees who are unwilling or unable to provide accurate financial records may be hiding something.
A. Common Reasons Trustees Stall
- They’ve mismanaged funds and fear exposure
- They’ve made unauthorized distributions to themselves or others
- They’ve comingled personal assets with trust assets
- They don’t understand their duties and are in over their heads
- They’re hoping beneficiaries will back down or give up
If a trustee consistently avoids providing information, it’s time to consider legal remedies.
III. Spotting Trouble: Red Flags in Trust Accountings
When it comes to trust accounting disputes, beneficiaries must be alert to signs of mismanagement hidden in vague, incomplete, or overly complex financial documents. Even when a trustee provides an accounting, not all records are created equal—some may obscure more than they reveal.
Here are common signs that something isn’t right:
A. Vague or Incomplete Records
If expenses are labeled generically (“miscellaneous,” “reimbursements”) without supporting receipts or details, that’s a problem. Beneficiaries are entitled to know exactly how trust funds are being spent.
B. Missing or Delayed Accountings
An outright failure to provide an accounting after a year—or after a formal written request—is a breach of duty. So is submitting one after extensive delays with no justification.
C. Unexplained Drops in Trust Value
If the trust’s value has declined significantly without explanation—especially in stable or appreciating markets—it may indicate poor investment decisions or unauthorized withdrawals.
D. Conflicts of Interest
If the trustee has used trust funds to pay themselves or their family members without prior approval, this raises serious questions of self-dealing.
E. Unusual Transactions
Sales of property at below-market rates, frequent cash withdrawals, or shifting assets into hard-to-trace investments like cryptocurrency should all trigger scrutiny.
For a deeper exploration of how financial manipulation and undue influence impact trust and estate cases, consider reading The Wolf at the Door by Michael Hackard.
IV. Beneficiary Rights: How to Demand Accountability
In many trust accounting disputes, the first critical step beneficiaries can take is submitting a formal written demand for an accounting under California Probate Code. This action not only initiates the legal process but also helps document the trustee’s response—or lack thereof—which can be pivotal if litigation becomes necessary.
A. Making a Formal Demand
The first step is often a formal written request for accounting under Probate Code §16062 and §17200. This puts the trustee on notice and starts a paper trail.
Your letter should:
- Cite the relevant probate code sections
- Specify the period for which you’re requesting an accounting
- Request supporting documentation (receipts, bank statements, tax returns)
- Set a reasonable deadline (typically 30–60 days)
B. Filing a Petition in Probate Court
If the trustee ignores your request or provides a deficient response, your attorney can file a petition with the probate court. This petition can seek:
- A court-ordered accounting
- Removal of the trustee
- Surcharge (damages) for any proven losses
- Attorneys’ fees (in some cases)
V. Litigation Strategies: Turning Numbers Into Leverage
Once litigation begins, the focus shifts to discovery—gathering evidence to support your claims and expose mismanagement.
A. Financial Forensics
A skilled forensic accountant can be invaluable. They analyze bank statements, cross-reference tax returns, trace questionable transactions, and build a timeline of activity.
B. Deposing the Trustee
Depositions can reveal inconsistencies, admissions of error, or lack of knowledge. If the trustee cannot explain key decisions or expenses, it strengthens your case.
C. Uncovering Patterns
Sometimes a single questionable transaction won’t win the case—but a pattern of behavior will. For example:
- Repeated cash withdrawals
- Recurring “loans” to the trustee
- Unreported rental income from trust property
- Asset sales to insiders at discounted rates
VI. Possible Outcomes: What Success Can Look Like
Litigation over accounting disputes can lead to several possible outcomes—some through court judgment, others through settlement.
A. Court-Ordered Accounting
If no accounting has been provided, the court may order the trustee to deliver one within a set time frame—often with strict oversight.
B. Trustee Removal
If mismanagement is proven, the court may remove the trustee and appoint a neutral third party. This is common in cases involving family conflict.
C. Financial Recovery (Surcharge)
If the trustee caused financial loss—through embezzlement, self-dealing, or poor investment decisions—the court may order a surcharge, requiring them to repay the trust.
D. Settlement
Many accounting disputes resolve outside of court. Trustees often agree to resign and repay funds in exchange for a release from further liability. This can be faster and less emotionally taxing than full litigation.
VII. Special Considerations in Family Trustee Cases
When the trustee is a relative, things get complicated. Emotions run high, and family history can cloud judgment on all sides.
A. Psychological Warfare
Family trustees may use guilt, manipulation, or social pressure to avoid scrutiny. They may accuse you of greed or betrayal. Don’t fall for it. Seeking accountability is not selfish—it’s responsible.
B. Sibling Rivalries
When one sibling is trustee and others are beneficiaries, long-standing tensions often resurface. Keep the focus on the numbers and the law, not old arguments.
C. Inheritance Inequities
Accountings often reveal “accidental” favoritism—like paying one sibling’s mortgage with trust funds while denying others equal access. These discrepancies may justify legal action.
VIII. When to Call a Lawyer
Accounting disputes may start with confusion—but they often end in court. If you’re seeing any of the following signs, it’s time to consult a trust litigation attorney:
- You’ve requested an accounting and received no response
- You received an accounting that’s incomplete, confusing, or suspicious
- You suspect the trustee is stealing, hiding, or mishandling assets
- Other beneficiaries have similar concerns
- You’re being threatened, manipulated, or intimidated for asking questions
Final Words
Trust accounting disputes reveal that while numbers don’t lie, they can be twisted, obscured, or hidden. That’s why accountings are one of the most powerful tools beneficiaries have for holding trustees accountable. When the figures don’t add up—or don’t appear at all—it’s often the first clue that something is deeply wrong.
At Hackard Law, we’ve helped countless clients use accounting disputes as the foundation for successful legal action. We know how to cut through smokescreens, expose wrongdoing, and protect what’s rightfully yours.
You don’t have to accept secrecy. You don’t have to accept abuse. If your trustee won’t give you answers, we’ll help you get them—through skillful negotiation, strategic litigation, and fearless advocacy.