Saratoga Trust and Estate Disputes

In brief: In California, a no-contest clause is enforced only in limited situations, most importantly against a direct contest brought without probable cause (Probate Code § 21311). A beneficiary with a reasonable, evidence-based challenge usually does not forfeit an inheritance by bringing it. Hackard Law handles these cases on contingency: no fee and no costs if there is no recovery, unless your written agreement provides otherwise.

Saratoga estates are often large, and many trusts here include a no-contest clause. Families read it as a gag order. It is narrower than it looks.

Named for a spa

Once called McCarthysville and then Toll Gate, the town was renamed in 1865 for Saratoga Springs, New York, because its mineral springs resembled Congress Springs there. Hakone Gardens, built between 1917 and 1929, is one of the oldest Japanese-style residential gardens in the Western Hemisphere. Saratoga incorporated in 1956.

The no-contest clause

For trusts and wills that became irrevocable on or after January 1, 2001, a no-contest clause can be enforced only against a direct contest brought without probable cause, and, if the clause expressly says so, a challenge to a transfer on the ground that the transferor did not own the property, or a creditor’s claim (Probate Code §§ 21311, 21315).

Probable cause exists if, when the contest is filed, the facts known to the contestant would make a reasonable person believe there is a reasonable likelihood the relief will be granted after further investigation or discovery. Many claims are not direct contests at all: a petition for an accounting, to remove a trustee, or to recover property is usually not a contest of the trust’s validity.

Warning signs

  • A no-contest clause added in the same late amendment that cut you out.
  • A trustee who threatens disinheritance when you ask questions.
  • A clause that tries to reach requests for information or accountings.
  • Pressure to sign a release before you have seen the trust or an account.

Saratoga at a glance

  • Population: 31,051 (2020 Census); 30,418 (2025 estimate)
  • Residents 65 and older: 26.5%
  • Median home value: $2,000,000 or more
  • Owner-occupied homes: 86.4%

Source: U.S. Census Bureau, 2020 Census, 2025 population estimates, and American Community Survey 2020–2024.

Where your case is heard

Trust and probate cases for Saratoga are heard in the Probate Division of Santa Clara County Superior Court, Downtown Superior Court, 191 North First Street, San José, California 95113, approximately 13 driving miles from Saratoga. Actual distance varies by starting point and route. Hackard Law’s office is in Sacramento County. The firm handles matters in Santa Clara County Superior Court and throughout California.

How fees work

Hackard Law represents families on a contingency basis. The fee is a percentage of the recovery, stated in a written agreement before work begins. The firm advances the costs of the case, which are repaid from the recovery. If there is no recovery, you owe no fee and no costs, unless your written agreement provides otherwise.

Frequently Asked Questions

Not necessarily. California enforces a no-contest clause against a direct contest only if it was brought without probable cause (Probate Code § 21311). A beneficiary with a reasonable, evidence-based challenge usually does not forfeit an inheritance by bringing it.

Probable cause exists if, when the contest is filed, the facts known to the contestant would cause a reasonable person to believe there is a reasonable likelihood the requested relief will be granted after an opportunity for investigation and discovery (Probate Code § 21311(b)).

Generally no. A no-contest clause is enforced against a direct contest of the instrument’s validity brought without probable cause, and in two other narrow situations the clause must spell out (Probate Code § 21311). Requests for information or an accounting are not direct contests.

Michael Hackard
Michael HackardHackard Law
California State Bar #71067

Talk to Hackard Law

The first conversation is about what happened and when.

Call the Sage: (916) 313-3030

Hackard Law’s office is in Sacramento County.

Hackard Law represents families throughout California. hackardlaw.com

Please do not send documents until we ask for them.